Free software doing better panorama stitching than Photoshop CS4

Post date Posted Saturday, June 27, 2009 at 10:44 am by Jason Cartwright

Whilst doing some further testing of the new camera on the iPhone 3GS, I decided to create a panorama. In considering which software to use, I had two immediate options.

The latest version of Windows Live Photo Gallery which I use to manage my photo collection contains a ‘Create panoramic photo’ feature.

 Windows Live Photo Gallery - Create Panorama

I also have Adobe Photoshop CS4 which includes ‘Photomerge’.

Photoshop CS4 Photomerge

Naturally, my assumption had always been the expensive pro software would do a better job at stitching photos together. As demonstrated below, it seems this is not the case.

Windows Live Photo Gallery
iPhone 3GS Stitch WLPG 

Photoshop CS4
iPhone-3GS-Stitch-Photoshop-CS4

Whilst they may look a like, upon closer inspection, you’ll see there are actually significant stitching issues on the when using Photoshop.

Photoshop CS4 Stiching errors

So certainly in this instance, the free application, Windows Live Photo Gallery actually does a better job of panorama stitching.


Social Tiles
Like us on Facebook Follow techAU on Twitter Find us on LinkedIn Check out the photos at Flickr Watch the latest videos at YouTube Friend techAU on Digg Add techAU on Google+ Follow techAU on iTunes Ping. Follow techAU on Foursquare SocialZune
SocialTiles2 Visit TechWebcast Subscribe to techAU's news feed Email techAU, tips, suggestions, feedback
WriterTiles View all posts by Bryce View all posts by Nick Ayre View all posts by Jason Cartwright View all posts by Jack View all posts by James View all posts by Nick Merry View all posts by Jenna Pitcher View all posts by Daniel Yacoub View all posts by Craig Lees View all posts by Dame View all posts by Daniel K View all posts by Liza